otkaznik (otkaznik) wrote,

...If this is true—if Russians are dying for lack of hope, as they seem to be—then the question that is still looking for its researcher is, Why haven’t Russians experienced hope in the last quarter century? Or, more precisely in light of the grim continuity of Russian death, What happened to Russians over the course of the Soviet century that has rendered them incapable of hope? In The Origins of Totalitarianism Hannah Arendt argues that totalitarian rule is truly possible only in countries that are large enough to be able to afford depopulation. The Soviet Union proved itself to be just such a country on at least three occasions in the twentieth century—teaching its citizens in the process that their lives are worthless. Is it possible that this knowledge has been passed from generation to generation enough times that most Russians are now born with it and this is why they are born with a Bangladesh-level life expectancy? Is it also possible that other post-Soviet states, by breaking off from Moscow, have reclaimed some of their ability to hope, and this is why even Russia’s closest cultural and geographic cousins, such as Belarus and Ukraine, aren’t dying off as fast? If so, Russia is dying of a broken heart—also known as cardiovascular disease.

Tags: книги

  • (no subject)

    Все же Пинкер большой молодец: The left tend to be sympathetic to yet another movement that subordinates human interests to a transcendent entity,…

  • Старческое

    В доступном мне сетевом мире люди, замечу не самые глупые люди, азартно обсуждают достоинства книжек Терри Пратчетта. Не в первый раз. А я никогда не…

  • (no subject)

    В интересной книжке Дмитрия Травина «Особый путь России» читаю: Даже применительно к СССР трудно говорить о том, что государство…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

  • 1 comment